Nicola Sturgeon mocked for proposed Bill to pardon witches: 'I'm struggling to care'

The new Bill could see thousands of Scots convicted of witchcraft legally pardoned after almost 300 years

Published

Nicola Strugeon has been mocked over a new Bill which could see thousands of Scots convicted of witchcraft legally pardoned after almost 300 years.

Natalie Don, the SNP MSP for Renfrewshire North and West, has launched consultation on a Member’s Bill to “right the historic wrong of witchcraft convictions” and give legal pardons to those convicted.

Rebecca Jane
Rebecca Jane

It follows a posthumous apology from First Minister Nicola Sturgeon on International Women’s Day, in March, to those convicted, vilified or executed under the Witchcraft 1563 Act.

During a debate on GB News’ Dan Wootton Tonight, host Patrick Christys asked broadcaster and author Rebecca Jane whether witches should be pardoned.

To which Ms Jane replied: “No sorry.”

She added: “It’s such a difficult situation because I’m really struggling to care.

“I just think that we’ve got so much bigger things going on in the world so what is the point in doing this now.

“What is it going to achieve, what is it going to help, I don’t understand.

“The other point as well is we’re talking about things that happened 300 years ago.

“How do we know that these people weren’t actually committing crimes? How can we go back so far to know what is right and what is wrong?”

Nicola Sturgeon
Nicola Sturgeon

Estimates suggest around 4,000 Scots were accused of the crime, which was in law until 1736, with around 85 percent of those convicted being women.

Campaigners have been trying to secure a legal pardon for around 200 years for the approximately 2,500 people who were convicted of breaking the law.

While the convictions occurred centuries ago, it is hoped the pardons would send a message to other countries who still criminalise those accused of witchcraft that the punishment is “deplorable”.

Ms Don said: “The recent formal apology from the First Minister on International Women’s Day was welcomed by campaigners in Scotland and recognised around the world as a statement of intent.

“It was a powerful and incredibly important first step in righting the historic wrong of ‘witchcraft’ accusations, arrests and executions.

“My Member’s Bill will hopefully be the next step towards that and, if passed, it will make clear that the people convicted of witchcraft all those years ago should never have faced the injustice of being labelled as criminals.

“By issuing official pardons for all those convicted of witchcraft, we will be sending a strong message to the wide world – some parts of which, women still face prosecution for being accused of witchcraft – that Scotland recognises what happened to these people as a deplorable miscarriage of justice.

“It is also about influencing the gendered and patriarchal attitudes which, unfortunately, still exists in our society today – and making it clear that Scotland does not tolerate discrimination in any way.”

The Witches of Scotland campaign group said: “We are absolutely delighted to see Natalie Don’s Bill reach this stage and are hopeful that this will bring about some posthumous justice to the thousands of people who were executed by the state during the witch hunts.

“This will also signal to other countries around the world where accusations of witchcraft are a very real and current issue that this is not acceptable in the modern day.